When Children Become Pawns: Understanding High-Conflict Divorce and Co-Parenting
by Jessica Anne Pressler, LCSW
Divorce is never easy, but for some families, the end of a marriage becomes the beginning of a different kind of nightmare. When one parent has personality traits that make healthy co-parenting nearly impossible, children often find themselves caught in the crossfire of an ongoing battle that should have ended when the papers were signed.
Understanding the Underlying Dynamics
High-conflict divorces often involve parents with certain personality characteristics that make letting go particularly difficult. These individuals frequently display traits consistent with Cluster B personality disorders, including narcissistic, borderline, histrionic, and antisocial patterns. The divorce process itself can trigger intense psychological reactions in individuals with these predispositions, as it represents a fundamental threat to their sense of control, identity, and self-worth. Understanding these underlying dynamics is crucial for legal professionals, mental health practitioners, and family members trying to navigate these treacherous waters.
Narcissistic personality traits play a particularly destructive role in high-conflict divorce situations. Individuals with these characteristics possess an intense need for control and admiration that makes the perceived rejection of divorce unbearable. They often view their ex-spouse not as a separate individual with legitimate grievances, but as an extension of themselves who has betrayed them in the most fundamental way. This perspective makes it nearly impossible for them to accept responsibility for relationship failures or to separate their own emotional needs from their children's wellbeing. Their tendency to see situations in black-and-white terms means that if they cannot be the "good parent," then their ex-spouse must be cast as the "bad parent," regardless of reality.
Borderline personality patterns create a different but equally destructive dynamic in high-conflict divorce. The intense fear of abandonment that characterizes this condition becomes magnified during divorce proceedings, leading to desperate attempts to maintain connection and control. These individuals often experience severe emotional dysregulation that significantly impairs their decision-making abilities, particularly when it comes to prioritizing their children's needs over their own emotional distress. The splitting behaviors common in borderline patterns result in extreme idealization or devaluation of the ex-spouse, making consistent co-parenting nearly impossible as the individual's perception shifts dramatically based on their current emotional state.
Antisocial characteristics, while less common, create perhaps the most challenging high-conflict divorce scenarios. These individuals demonstrate a fundamental disregard for court orders, social norms, and the emotional wellbeing of their children. They approach relationships, including co-parenting, as power struggles to be won rather than cooperative endeavors focused on child welfare. Their capacity for manipulation and deceit, combined with a notable lack of empathy, makes them particularly skilled at using children as weapons while appearing reasonable to outside observers.
How Children Become Weapons
When a parent cannot accept the end of their marriage or relinquish control over their former spouse, children unfortunately become the most accessible tool for continued influence and punishment. This weaponization of children takes many forms, each more heartbreaking than the last, and often occurs simultaneously across multiple domains of the child's life.
Parental alienation represents one of the most psychologically damaging forms of child weaponization. This systematic process involves the deliberate undermining of the child's relationship with the targeted parent through sustained manipulation, lies, and emotional coercion. The alienating parent creates a campaign of denigration against the other parent, sharing inappropriate adult information about divorce proceedings, finances, or alleged wrongdoings. Children are coached to reject visits, taught to view normal parenting behaviors as threatening or harmful, and made to feel disloyal or guilty for expressing love toward the targeted parent. The alienating parent often presents themselves as the victim while simultaneously orchestrating the destruction of the parent-child relationship they claim to be protecting.
Information warfare transforms children into unwilling spies and messengers in their parents' ongoing conflict. Children are interrogated about their time with the other parent, asked inappropriate questions about their other parent's activities, relationships, living situation, or financial status. They are forced to carry messages between parents, often hostile or manipulative communications disguised as necessary information sharing. This places children in impossible loyalty binds where any information they share feels like a betrayal of one parent or the other. The psychological burden of constantly monitoring and reporting on a parent they love creates chronic anxiety and teaches children that relationships are fundamentally unsafe and transactional.
Financial manipulation provides another avenue for continued control and punishment that directly impacts children's wellbeing. The high-conflict parent may deliberately withhold financial support, use children's activities, medical needs, or educational expenses as bargaining chips, or create artificial financial crises to force ongoing contact and conflict. They might promise children expensive gifts or experiences contingent on their behavior toward the other parent, or conversely, threaten to withdraw financial support for activities the child enjoys if they maintain a relationship with the targeted parent. This economic abuse extends the reach of the high-conflict parent's control far beyond the divorce decree.
Legal system abuse has become an increasingly common weapon in high-conflict divorces, with some parents filing dozens or even hundreds of motions, complaints, and emergency petitions designed not to resolve legitimate issues but to harass, exhaust, and financially devastate the other parent. Each court appearance becomes an opportunity to inflict emotional and financial damage while positioning themselves as the concerned parent seeking protection for their children. False allegations of abuse, neglect, or substance use are common tactics, forcing the targeted parent to defend themselves repeatedly while children are subjected to unnecessary investigations, interviews, and disruptions to their relationships.
The emotional manipulation of children perhaps represents the cruelest form of weaponization because it directly corrupts the parent-child relationship that should provide safety and unconditional love. High-conflict parents make children feel responsible for their emotional wellbeing, sharing inappropriate details about their sadness, loneliness, or financial struggles in ways that burden children with adult responsibilities. They create loyalty tests where children must demonstrate their love through rejection of the other parent, use guilt and fear to control children's behavior and preferences, and manufacture crises or emergencies during the other parent's time to disrupt the relationship and reinforce their own importance.
The Failures and Limitations of the Court System
Our family court system, while well-intentioned and designed to protect children's best interests, often struggles to address high-conflict situations effectively due to systemic limitations that inadvertently enable continued abuse. Understanding these limitations is crucial for families navigating these systems and for advocates working to improve them.
The most significant limitation facing family courts is the scarcity of time and resources available to make complex decisions about family dynamics. Judges are typically allocated brief windows—sometimes as little as 15-30 minutes—to make life-altering decisions about families they barely know. The nuanced dynamics of personality disorders, emotional abuse, and parental alienation cannot be adequately assessed in such limited timeframes. This time pressure often leads to decisions based on incomplete information or surface-level presentations that may not reflect the true family dynamics.
The court system's focus on legal facts rather than emotional reality creates another significant barrier to protecting children in high-conflict situations. Courts excel at dividing assets, establishing parenting schedules, and enforcing concrete obligations, but they often miss the subtle psychological warfare happening between parents. Emotional abuse, manipulation, and alienation leave no physical evidence, making them extraordinarily difficult to prove using traditional legal standards of evidence. The high-conflict parent often presents as reasonable, cooperative, and concerned about the children's wellbeing, while the targeted parent may appear angry, defensive, or emotional due to the ongoing abuse they are experiencing.
The adversarial nature of the legal system can actually escalate conflict rather than resolve it, providing high-conflict individuals with additional ammunition for their ongoing battles. Each motion filed, each hearing scheduled, and each order entered becomes part of the narrative the high-conflict parent constructs about their victimization and their ex-spouse's unfitness. The legal process itself becomes weaponized, with the high-conflict parent using procedural rules, discovery requests, and contempt motions as tools of harassment rather than genuine attempts to resolve disputes in the children's best interests.
Perhaps most concerning is the inadequate training many legal professionals receive regarding personality disorders, trauma responses, and child development. Judges, attorneys, and court staff may lack the specialized knowledge needed to recognize the signs of parental alienation, understand the long-term impacts of emotional abuse on children, or differentiate between genuine concerns about child safety and manipulative allegations designed to gain tactical advantage. This knowledge gap can result in well-intentioned but harmful decisions that inadvertently reward the high-conflict parent's behavior while further traumatizing children and the targeted parent.
How the Court System Can Help
Despite these significant limitations, there are tools, approaches, and reforms that can make a substantial difference in protecting children and families affected by high-conflict divorce. These interventions require specialized training, adequate resources, and a willingness to move beyond traditional adversarial approaches to family law.
Guardian ad Litem appointments represent one of the most valuable tools available to family courts dealing with high-conflict situations. These court-appointed advocates, typically attorneys or mental health professionals with specialized training, are tasked with representing the children's best interests rather than either parent's position. Unlike parents or their attorneys, Guardians ad Litem have the time and authority to conduct extensive investigations into family dynamics, interview children in age-appropriate settings, consult with teachers and therapists, and observe parent-child interactions over extended periods. Their recommendations carry significant weight with judges because they are seen as neutral parties focused solely on child welfare.
Parenting coordinators provide another crucial intervention for high-conflict families. These mental health professionals with specialized training in both clinical practice and family law can make binding decisions about day-to-day parenting issues without requiring court intervention. This reduces opportunities for ongoing conflict while ensuring that children's immediate needs are addressed promptly. Effective parenting coordinators understand the dynamics of high-conflict divorce and can implement strategies to minimize manipulation while maintaining focus on children's wellbeing.
Court-ordered psychological evaluations, when conducted by qualified professionals with expertise in personality disorders and family systems, can provide crucial insights into family dynamics that are not apparent during brief court hearings. Comprehensive evaluations include psychological testing of parents, clinical interviews with children, observation of parent-child interactions, and consultation with collateral sources such as teachers, therapists, and family members. These evaluations can identify personality disorders, assess parenting capacity, and make specific recommendations for custody arrangements, therapeutic interventions, and protective measures.
Structured parenting plans that minimize opportunities for conflict and manipulation represent another important tool for protecting children in high-conflict situations. These detailed agreements specify exactly when, where, and how parenting time exchanges will occur, establish clear communication protocols between parents, and outline consequences for violations. Effective high-conflict parenting plans often include provisions for supervised exchanges at neutral locations, communication through specialized apps that monitor and record all interactions, and specific procedures for making decisions about children's medical, educational, and extracurricular needs.
Supervised visitation programs, while sometimes seen as punitive, can be crucial for maintaining parent-child relationships while ensuring children's safety and wellbeing. These programs provide neutral, trained supervisors who can observe parent-child interactions, intervene if concerning behaviors occur, and document the quality of the relationship over time. For children who have been subjected to parental alienation, supervised visitation can provide a safe space to reconnect with the targeted parent without pressure or interference from the alienating parent.
Therapeutic Interventions and Support
Healing from the trauma of high-conflict divorce requires specialized therapeutic approaches that address the unique psychological impacts of parental conflict, alienation, and emotional abuse. Traditional therapy approaches may be insufficient or even counterproductive if therapists lack understanding of these complex family dynamics.
Children affected by high-conflict divorce require therapeutic interventions that are specifically tailored to their developmental stage and the particular traumas they have experienced. Play therapy provides an especially valuable approach for younger children who lack the verbal skills to express their complex emotions about their parents' conflict. Through play, children can process feelings of guilt, fear, and confusion while developing healthier coping mechanisms. The play therapy process helps children understand that they are not responsible for their parents' problems and that it is safe and appropriate to love both parents.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy approaches have shown significant effectiveness with school-age children and adolescents affected by parental conflict. These interventions help children identify and challenge distorted thinking patterns that may have been instilled through parental alienation or ongoing conflict exposure. Children learn to recognize manipulation tactics, develop critical thinking skills, and build emotional regulation abilities that serve them throughout their lives. CBT approaches also address the anxiety, depression, and behavioral problems that commonly result from chronic exposure to parental conflict.
Family therapy presents unique challenges in high-conflict divorce situations because the source of trauma often lies within the family system itself. However, when conducted by therapists with specialized training in high-conflict dynamics, family therapy can be beneficial for rebuilding damaged relationships between children and targeted parents. These interventions must be carefully structured to prevent further manipulation or alienation and may require extended periods of individual work before joint sessions can occur safely.
Targeted parents require specialized therapeutic support that addresses the unique trauma of watching their children being manipulated and turned against them while feeling powerless to stop the process. Trauma-informed therapy approaches help these parents process the psychological impact of ongoing harassment, manipulation, and loss while developing strategies for maintaining their emotional wellbeing. Co-parenting coaching provides practical tools for protecting children while maintaining necessary communication with the high-conflict parent, including strategies for documenting concerning behaviors, responding to manipulation attempts, and prioritizing children's needs despite ongoing conflict.
Support groups specifically designed for parents dealing with alienation and high-conflict divorce provide crucial peer connection and validation. These groups offer understanding that is difficult to find elsewhere, as the experiences of targeted parents are often misunderstood by well-meaning friends and family members who cannot comprehend the deliberate nature of parental alienation. Group members share practical strategies, provide emotional support during particularly difficult periods, and offer hope for eventual reunification with their children.
High-conflict parents themselves require specialized therapeutic interventions that address the underlying personality patterns and emotional dysregulation that drive their destructive behaviors. Dialectical Behavior Therapy has shown promise for individuals with borderline personality traits, teaching crucial skills in emotional regulation, distress tolerance, and interpersonal effectiveness. These skills can help high-conflict parents develop healthier ways of managing the intense emotions triggered by divorce and co-parenting challenges.
Personality disorder treatment requires long-term commitment and specialized approaches that address the deep-seated patterns of thinking and behavior that contribute to high-conflict dynamics. Schema therapy, mentalization-based therapy, and other specialized approaches have shown effectiveness with various personality disorders, though treatment success often depends on the individual's willingness to acknowledge problematic behaviors and commit to genuine change.
Moving Forward with Hope
While high-conflict divorce creates tremendous challenges for families, legal systems, and mental health professionals, there is genuine hope for healing and recovery when appropriate interventions are implemented. Children demonstrate remarkable resilience when provided with proper support, understanding, and protection from ongoing conflict. Research indicates that children who receive appropriate therapeutic intervention and maintain relationships with psychologically healthy adults can overcome even severe parental alienation and develop healthy relationship patterns in their own lives.
For families currently struggling with high-conflict divorce dynamics, several key strategies can help protect children and promote eventual healing. Documentation of concerning behaviors should be objective, specific, and consistent, focusing on observable actions rather than interpretations or emotional reactions. This documentation can be crucial for legal proceedings and therapeutic interventions. Prioritizing children's emotional safety above all other considerations, including the desire to maintain relationships or avoid conflict, is essential for their long-term wellbeing.
Professional help from practitioners specifically trained in high-conflict dynamics, parental alienation, and personality disorders is crucial, as traditional approaches may be insufficient or even harmful in these complex situations. Please check out the book Been There Got Out and beentheregotout.com for excellent advice and support. Building a support network of understanding friends, family members, and professionals provides essential emotional sustenance during what can be years-long battles for children's wellbeing.
For the broader community, continued advocacy for improved training for legal professionals, increased funding for family court resources, and greater awareness of how personality disorders impact family systems is essential. Every child deserves to love both parents without fear, guilt, or manipulation, and achieving this goal requires systemic changes in how we approach high-conflict family situations.
The development of specialized family courts with judges trained in mental health issues, the expansion of therapeutic intervention programs, and the implementation of evidence-based practices for addressing parental alienation represent important steps forward. However, much work remains to be done in educating professionals, developing effective interventions, and creating systems that truly prioritize children's wellbeing over parental rights or legal efficiency.
The journey through high-conflict divorce is long, difficult, and often heartbreaking, but with proper support, understanding, and intervention, families can find their way to healthier dynamics. Children who experience these situations are not doomed to repeat the patterns they witnessed—with appropriate help, they can break cycles of conflict and manipulation and build healthy, loving relationships in their own lives. The scars may remain, but healing is possible, and hope should never be abandoned, even in the darkest moments of these family tragedies.
If you're currently dealing with a high-conflict divorce situation, please reach out to a mental health professional who specializes in family systems and high-conflict dynamics. You don't have to navigate this alone. Please check out beentheregotout.com is an excellent resource.
DISCLAIMER:
The contents of this website; blog, video, articles, media, social media, book, and references, are ONLY for informational and entertainment purposes. It is NOT intended as a psychological service, diagnostic tool, medical treatment, personal advice, counseling, or determination of risk and should not be used as a substitute for treatment by psychological or medical services.
Please seek consultation by an appropriate healthcare provider.
Call 911 if there is an emergency.
Call or text 988, which is the National Suicide and Crisis Lifeline,
Call National Suicidal Prevention Hotline at 1-800-273-8255 to talk to someone 24/7 if needed. Call National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233 to talk to someone 24/7 if needed.
Looking at, reading, listening to any information on my website, social media, YouTube, or book, and communicating with me by email or any other communication with me, you acknowledge and agree that we do not have a professional/client relationship. Use of this site and information associated with this site is solely at the visitor’s own risk.
